Repair or replace your deck? An honest checklist
By Jeff Rabkin, JustFix Wood · Published September 27, 2026
I don't build new decks, so I have no reason to talk you into one. Here's the checklist I go through when I look at a deck.
Signs a repair makes sense
- The rot or damage is limited to boards, a few joists, a stair or a section of railing.
- The posts are solid at the bottom and the deck doesn't sway when you push on it.
- The ledger (the board bolted to the house) is solid, dry, and properly fastened.
- You're happy with the size and layout of the deck.
Signs replacement is worth considering
- Rot in the ledger or in the house framing behind it.
- Most posts or joists are soft, not just a few.
- The footings have moved and the deck has settled out of level in several places.
- You want a different size or shape anyway, so repair money would be wasted.
The middle ground
Plenty of decks fall in between. A common fix is solid framing with new boards on top, or new stairs and railings on an otherwise sound deck. That buys years for much less than a rebuild.
If your deck is in the middle, the photos will usually show it. Send them over and I'll give you a price range for the repair and tell you straight if I think it's a waste of money.
Need this fixed?